| POS | FIRST | LAST | RARITY | ICONS | TEAM | SAL | STRATEGY | |
| C | Salvador | Perez | U | SL, GG | Kansas City | 300 | Bridging The Gap | |
| 1B | Anthony | Rizzo | R | GG | Chicago (N) | 410 | Bang Bang | |
| 2B | Ian | Kinsler | U | GG | San Diego | 235 | Breathing Room 2.0 | |
| 3B | Kyle | Seager | C | Seattle | 125 | Cut The Lights | ||
| SS | Andrelton | Simmons | U | GG | Los Angeles (A) | 390 | Hit The Road Jack | |
| LF/RF | Alex | Gordon | C | GG | Kansas City | 125 | On Deck Circle | |
| LF/RF | Brett | Gardner | C | New York (A) | 280 | Opposite Way | ||
| CF | Ender | Inciarte | U | GG | Atlanta | 370 | Circus Act | |
| DH | Yoan | Moncada | C | Chicago (A) | 120 | Claustrophobia | ||
| B | Amed | Rosario | C | New York (N) | 120 | Daylight Play | ||
| B | John | Hicks | C | Detroit | 100 | Eat The Ball | ||
| B | Pedro | Alvarez | C | Miami | 50 | Grab And Go | ||
| Jack In The Box | ||||||||
| SP | Zack | Greinke | R | GG | Arizona | 520 | Pitch Out | |
| SP | Luis | Castillo | U | Cincinnati | 395 | Bat On Ball | ||
| SP | Kyle | Freeland | U | Colorado | 395 | Better 1 Out Than 2 | ||
| SP | Joe | Musgrove | C | Pittsburgh | 300 | Cloud Nine | ||
| SP | Eric | Lauer | C | San Diego | 255 | Never Enough | ||
| RP | Andrew | Miller | U | St. Louis | 295 | Stealing Signs | ||
| RP | Tyler | Olson | C | Cleveland | 210 | Unsung Hero | ||
| RP | Will | Harris | C | Houston | 205 | Losing Steam | ||
| RP | Ken | Giles | C | Toronto | 195 | Alex Cora | ||
| RP | Jeremy | Jeffress | C | Milwaukee | 170 | STADIUMS | ||
| RP | Mike | Wright | C | Baltimore | 150 | Atlanta | ||
| RP | Heath | Hembree | C | Boston | 150 | Boston | ||
| RP | Mark | Melancon | C | San Francisco | 105 | Texas |
| POS | FIRST | LAST | RARITY | ICONS | TEAM | SAL | STRATEGY | |
| C | Yadier | Molina | U | GG | St. Louis | 295 | Ace in the Hole | |
| 1B | Yonder | Alonso | C | Chicago (A) | 175 | Breathing Room 2.0 | ||
| 2B | Dee | Gordon | C | Seattle | 280 | Cut the Lights | ||
| 3B | Renato | Nunez | C | Baltimore | 180 | Effectively Wild | ||
| SS | Dansby | Swanson | C | Atlanta | 190 | Hangin' K's | ||
| LF/RF | Max | Kepler | C | Minnesota | 235 | Chain Reaction | ||
| LF/RF | Jarrod | Dyson | C | Arizona | 200 | On Deck Circle | ||
| CF | Starling | Marte | U | SB | Pittsburgh | 315 | Rib-Eye Steak 2.0 | |
| DH | Justin | Upton | U | Los Angeles (A) | 300 | Ahead in the Count | ||
| B | Niko | Goodrum | C | Detroit | 110 | Back Burner | ||
| B | Martin | Prado | C | Miami | 50 | Choke Artist | ||
| B | Rajai | Davis | C | New York (N) | 50 | Get Hyphy | ||
| Grab and Go | ||||||||
| SP | Justin | Verlander | R | K | Houston | 580 | Jack in the Box | |
| SP | Carlos | Carrasco | U | Cleveland | 445 | Throwing Strikes | ||
| SP | Kyle | Hendricks | C | Chicago (N) | 400 | Clickbait | ||
| SP | Patrick | Corbin | U | K | Washington | 360 | Do or Die | |
| SP | Cole | Hamels | C | Chicago (N) | 335 | Four Corners | ||
| RP | Wade | Davis | R | SV | Colorado | 240 | Unsung Hero | |
| RP | Dellin | Betances | U | K | New York (A) | 230 | Walk This Way | |
| RP | Raisel | Igelsias | C | Cincinnati | 220 | Seeing is Believing | ||
| RP | Corey | Knebel | C | Milwaukee | 205 | Afternoon Shade | ||
| RP | Joe | Kelly | C | Los Angeles (N) | 175 | STADIUMS | ||
| RP | Jeurys | Familia | C | New York (N) | 155 | Baltimore | ||
| RP | Ryan | Tepera | C | Toronto | 140 | Pittsburgh | ||
| RP | Adam | Morgan | C | Philadelphia | 135 | Washington |
| POS | FIRST | LAST | RARITY | ICONS | TEAM | SAL | STRATEGY | |
| C | Mike | Zunino | C | Tampa Bay | 225 | Meatball Masher 2.0 | ||
| 1B | Matt | Carpenter | U | HR, R | St. Louis | 420 | Down And Away | |
| 2B | Daniel | Murphy | C | Colorado | 350 | Effectively Wild | ||
| 3B | Kris | Bryant | U | Chicago (N) | 385 | Grudge Match | ||
| SS | Francisco | Lindor | R | SL, R | Cleveland | 525 | Passed Ball | |
| LF/RF | Joey | Gallo | U | HR | Texas | 250 | Reading The Ball 2.0 | |
| LF/RF | Andrew | Benintendi | C | Boston | 315 | Who Run It? | ||
| CF | Aaron | Hicks | C | New York (A) | 340 | Muddy Track | ||
| DH | Khris | Davis | R | HR, RBI | Oakland | 350 | Ahead In The Count | |
| B | Ryan | Braun | C | Milwaukee | 160 | Choke Artist | ||
| B | Kendrys | Morales | C | Toronto | 110 | Circus Act | ||
| B | Mark | Trumbo | C | Baltimore | 50 | Front Loaded | ||
| Get Hyphy | ||||||||
| SP | Wade | LeBlanc | U | Seattle | 445 | Chugga Chugga | ||
| SP | Wei-Yin | Chen | C | Miami | 245 | Clickbait | ||
| SP | Anibal | Sanchez | C | Washington | 240 | Four Corners | ||
| SP | Steven | Matz | C | New York (N) | 195 | Homeward Bound | ||
| SP | Matt | Harvey | C | Los Angeles (A) | 150 | Never Enough | ||
| RP | Yoshihisa | Hirano | U | HL | Arizona | 230 | Rattled | |
| RP | Ryan | Pressly | U | Houston | 190 | Wandering Eye | ||
| RP | Scott | Alexander | C | Los Angeles (N) | 185 | It's A Trap! | ||
| RP | Drew | Steckenrider | C | Miami | 150 | The Long Con | ||
| RP | Buck | Farmer | C | Detroit | 115 | STADIUMS | ||
| RP | Amir | Garrett | C | Cincinnati | 110 | Detroit | ||
| RP | Trevor | Hildenberger | C | Minnesota | 95 | Philadelphia | ||
| RP | Sam | Dyson | C | San Francisco | 90 | St. Louis |
| POS | FIRST | LAST | RARITY | ICONS | TEAM | SAL | STRATEGY | |
| C | Erik | Kratz | C | Milwaukee | 95 | Round 'Em Up | ||
| 1B | Cody | Bellinger | C | Los Angeles (N) | 250 | Bang Bang | ||
| 2B | Javier | Baez | U | SL, RBI | Chicago (N) | 390 | Cut The Lights | |
| 3B | Wil | Myers | C | San Diego | 145 | Hit The Road Jack | ||
| SS | Trea | Turner | R | SB | Washington | 345 | Opposite Way | |
| LF/RF | Charlie | Blackmon | U | R | Colorado | 435 | Pulled It | |
| LF/RF | Andrew | McCutchen | C | Philadelphia | 325 | Rib-Eye Steak 2.0 | ||
| CF | Delino | DeShields Jr. | C | Texas | 320 | Losing Steam | ||
| DH | Mallex | Smith | U | SB | Seattle | 305 | Back Burner | |
| B | Adalberto | Mondesi | C | Kansas City | 190 | Choke Artist | ||
| B | Todd | Frazier | C | New York (N) | 190 | Claustrophobia | ||
| B | Scott | Schebler | C | Cincinnati | 135 | Ordinary Hero | ||
| Bat On Ball | ||||||||
| SP | Miles | Mikolas | R | W | St. Louis | 550 | Charged Up | |
| SP | Mike | Leake | U | Seattle | 370 | Cloud Nine | ||
| SP | Andrew | Heaney | U | Los Angeles (A) | 355 | Chugga Chugga | ||
| SP | Andrew | Triggs | C | Oakland | 175 | Disrespected | ||
| SP | Tyson | Ross | C | Detroit | 140 | Never Enough | ||
| RP | Taylor | Rogers | C | Minnesota | 240 | Pitch Count | ||
| RP | Tony | Watson | U | HL | San Francisco | 215 | Rattled | |
| RP | Dan | Otero | C | Cleveland | 165 | Walk This Way | ||
| RP | Nate | Jones | C | Chicago (A) | 155 | Frozen Fingers | ||
| RP | Andrew | Chafin | C | Arizona | 145 | STADIUMS | ||
| RP | Miguel | Castro | C | Baltimore | 135 | Los Angeles (A) | ||
| RP | Sam | Freeman | C | Atlanta | 135 | Miami | ||
| RP | Joe | Biagini | C | Toronto | 95 | Milwaukee |